|
Fall 2011
Performance-enhancing Sports
Aids:
Concerns about this Exploding Market
Nancy
Bonthius, PharmD, University of Iowa Children’s
Hospital
|
Common Ergogenic Aids
Anabolic-androgenic steroids
Steroid precursors
(androstenedione
and
dehydroepiandrosterone)
growth
hormone
Creatine
Protein/amino acids
Ephedra alkaloids
Nitric oxide producers
Energy drinks (especially high
caffeine products)
|
Performance-enhancing sports aids,
also called ergogenic aids, are
substances taken to improve athletic
abilities. These include legal and
illegal substances, as well as
marketed nutritional supplements.
Ergogenic aids may be taken orally,
injected, or inhaled. They have been
widely used by professional and elite
athletes for several decades. However,
research indicates that an increasing
number of younger athletes are
experimenting with these drugs to
improve both athletic ability and
appearance. The widespread use and
marketing of these products, in stores
and on the internet, are generating
significant health concerns.
Historical Use of Ergogenics
Ergogenic use by athletes to improve
athletic performance is not a new
practice. As early as 776 BC, the
Greek Olympians used substances, such
as mushrooms, dried figs, and
strychnine, to |
|
enhance performance. In 1889, Dr.
Brown-Sequard hypothesized
that testicles secreted substances
that acted as
physiologic regulators. Attempting to
confirm his assumption, he injected
himself with the extract of dog and
guinea pig testicles and perceived
that he had reversed his 72-year-old
body’s ailments.
This experiment helped lead to the
discovery of hormones in 1905 and the
isolation of testosterone in 1935. The
use of various hormones and steroid
precursors has dramatically increased
since the early 1960s, when commercial
anabolic androgenic steroids first
became available.
|
|
The “Winning at Any Cost” Mindset
In a 1987 survey of
elite Olympic caliber athletes, 195
out of 198 athletes (98%) said they
would use a banned substance if it
were absolutely undetectable and it
guaranteed victory. Additionally, >50%
of the athletes stated they would use
undetectable substances if it allowed
them to be a top athlete for five
years, but then resulted in death.
Today,
athletes go to great lengths to
increase athletic ability. Many young
athletes admit that the competitive
drive to win can be very intense. For
a growing number of athletes, winning
at all costs includes taking ergogenic
aids. Some athletes appear to benefit
from these products, but at what cost
and risk? The short and long-term
benefits of taking these products have
not been rigorously studied, nor have
the potential side effects. |
 |
|
No Food and Drug Administration (FDA)
Oversight
The Food and Drug Administration (FDA)
classifies sports supplements as
dietary supplements, and does not
require them to meet any standards or
regulations. Supplement manufacturers
are supposed to follow Good
Manufacturing Practices (GMP), but
these are essentially self-regulated
and self-reported guidelines. There
are no regulations that guarantee the
safety or purity of products sold as a
supplement.
Additionally, the FDA is prohibited
from removing a product from the
market unless the product has caused
proven medical harm. Most heath risks
from supplements are discovered only
after the product is on the market. It
is usually only after a supplement has
been linked to multiple serious health
risks or death that the FDA can remove
it from the market. Therefore,
supplements are:
-
Not guaranteed to meet product
potency or purity
-
Not required to meet the same
safety requirements as
prescription or over-the-counter
drug or food requirements
-
Not held to specific manufacturing
Standards
-
Not required to meet safety or
efficacy thresholds before
going on the market
-
Not required to be proven
effective for any claimed health
benefit
|
Ergogenic Use
390,000
10- to 14-year-olds admitted to
using sports supplements.
1 million 12- to 17-year-olds
admitted to using potentially
dangerous sports supplements.
Only 57% of 12th graders
perceived anabolic steroid use as
harmful.
70% of young people & 50% of their
parents could not identify any
specific negative side effects from
using sports supplements.
80% of young people have never
discussed sports supplements with
their parents. |
|
What Has Been Found in Supplements on
the U.S. Market?
An International Olympic Committee
study, conducted from 2000 to 2002,
showed that 18.8% of the 240
supplements purchased in the USA
surreptitiously contained steroids.
A study overseen by Informed Choice, a
non-profit coalition of dietary
supplements, found that 13 of the 52
supplements (25%) purchased at various
U.S. retailers surreptitiously
contained steroids and that six
(11.5%) contained banned stimulants.
Numerous studies have found that ~25%
of dietary supplements are
contaminated with heavy metals,
steroids, and/or medications not
listed on the labels. |
|



|
It is important to check supplement
labels for a seal of approval from a
legitimate, independent (third-party)
company. These independent companies
contract with supplement manufacturers
to assess and verify the purity and
content of their products. If
supplements do not have a seal of
approval, then they either have not
been analyzed by an independent
company or they have not met an
independent company’s standards.
Many supplements have labels that
falsely appear to contain seals of
approval, e.g., “GNC Approved.”
However, in many cases, these seals
are not from independent testing
companies.
ï
At left are three seals of
approval from legitimate, independent
companies.
Energy Drinks
Energy drinks are increasing in
popularity among athletes of all ages.
Caffeine is the main “energy”
ingredient in energy drinks, but they
also frequently contain other
ingredients, such as, vitamins,
glucuronolactone, ginseng, guarana,
and taurine. Familiar brand names
include Jolt, Red Bull, Rock Star, and
even some VitaWater products. It is
claimed that these products improve
alertness, stamina and reaction time.
Caffeine has been used for its
stimulant effects by endurance
athletes as a way to stay alert and
improve endurance. Its ability to
enhance performance, under certain
conditions, has been well documented.
However, consuming too much caffeine
often has negative effects on overall
performance, and has even led to the
deaths of athletes.
|
|
In the United
States, manufacturers are not required
to list the ingredients of energy
drinks. Therefore, it is difficult for
consumers to appreciate how much
caffeine they ingest with an energy
drink. In addition to acting as a
stimulant, caffeine is also a
diuretic. Thus, it can contribute to
dehydration in athletes. Ginseng and guarana also have stimulant effects in
the body and add to the danger of
these products. Considerable concern
remains regarding the negative effects
of energy drinks. Emergency room
visits arising from energy drink
consumption are becoming commonplace.
Current trends among students include
mixing energy drinks with alcohol at
parties and bars. Side effects of
energy drinks include dehydration,
nausea, nosebleeds, heart arrhythmias,
and death.
Creatine
Creatine is a natural substance that
the body uses to produce energy. The
daily requirement of creatine is 2g
per day. Humans produce half the daily
requirement, while the other half
comes from a balanced diet. Creatine
supplements are commonly used by
athletes in the hope that they will
provide quick bursts of energy.
Creatine supplementation can have some
athletic benefits, as it increases
strength and improves outcomes in
short duration, anaerobic events (such
as weightlifting or short sprints). It
does not improve endurance, since
prolonged muscle activity depends on
aerobic glycolysis.
Despite the
wide-spread use of creatine by young
athletes, little information exists
regarding its safety or efficacy in
children and teens. Creatine side
effects include dehydration, muscle
cramps, diarrhea, and renal function
compromise. Additionally, there is no
data to judge the effects of creatine
supplementation on the other tissues
that store creatine (such as the heart
and brain), and the effects of chronic
use are unknown. |
|
The amount of
protein that should be ingested per
day:
0.8g/kg
per day for normal activity
levels
1.0-1.2g/kg
per day for light-moderate
athletic training
1.4-1.7g/kg
per day for moderate-heavy
athletic training
(Limited data suggests up to)2g/kg
per day may be used for heavy
athletic training |
Protein/Amino Acids
Proteins provide critical amino acids
that serve as building blocks for new
muscle.
Fortunately, the higher intakes
recommended for athletes are easily
achieved in a well-balanced diet
without the use of supplements.
Common sources of dietary protein
include meat (5-7g protein/ounce) and
milk (8g protein/cup). Milk consists
primarily of two proteins: 80% casein
and 20% whey. Both of these proteins
are excellent sources of all essential
amino acids, but they differ in one
important aspect.
Whey is a
quickly-digested protein that provides
an immediate increase in the blood’s
amino acid content.
However, its effects are short-lived.
Casein is a slowly-digested protein
that provides a slower increase of
blood amino acids, and its effects
last much longer (7 hours). Drinking
16 to 32 ounces of chocolate milk within 20 to 30 minutes after weightlifting or
other strenuous |
|
exercise is the safest
way to efficiently build muscles.
Chocolate milk specifically is most
helpful because chocolate reduces
lactic acid that builds up during
strenuous exercise, while milk
provides an immediate source of both
protein and carbohydrates.
Protein supplements available on the
market consist primarily of casein,
whey, or both proteins. If an athlete
is set on using a protein supplement,
it is best to use a product that has
both whey and casein to maximize the
benefit. Side effects of protein
supplements include constipation, gas,
diarrhea, dehydration (especially
intravascular), and high prolactin
levels (if tainted with steroids).
Rare side effects have included liver,
renal, and heart disease.
Nitric Oxide
Producers
Considerable interest has been shown
by athletes in nitric oxide and
associated vasodilators to enhance
athletic performance. Nitric oxide is
a gas that is produced when an enzyme,
nitric oxide synthase (NOS), breaks
down L-arginine into L-citruline. The
most common way to increase nitric
oxide in the body is through exercise.
As the heart pumps with more pressure
to supply the muscles with blood,
arterial walls release nitric oxide
into blood. Nitric oxide dilates
vessel walls, allowing greater blood
flow. Athletes and youth have the most
optimal nitric oxide systems,
affecting their energy and
resilience.
The supplement market is now flooded
with products that contain L-arginine
for athletes. The theory is that the
athlete taking these products right
before working out will provide
maximal blood flow to the muscles. In
reality, this shunts blood away from
other vital organs, such as the brain,
heart, and kidneys.
Athletes also
theorize that by consuming these
products in combination with creatine
or protein supplements, these
supplements are delivered more
effectively to the muscles since the
vessels are dilated. Common side
effects of these products include
hypotension, fainting, dizziness,
nausea, diarrhea, changes in
electrolytes, and increased bleeding.
The long-term consequences of using
these products are unknown and may be
serious, particularly if they lead to
cardiac hypertrophy and heart failure.
Ephedra Alkaloids
Similar to amphetamine, ephedra is a
stimulant. Athletes use ephedra to
improve mental alertness, limit
fatigue, and reduce weight. In 2004,
the FDA banned the sale of ephedra
after it was linked to the sudden
deaths of three college and pro
athletes. However, some sports drinks
and energy foods still contain ephedra
or ephedra-like substances. It can
also be found in cold products, such
as pseudoephedrine (i.e., Sudafed).
Athletes are increasingly using these
products for their stimulant effects
to enhance performance. Side effects
include insomnia, tachycardia,
hypertension, heart attacks, seizures,
and death.
Growth Hormone
Growth hormone is a polypeptide
secreted by the anterior pituitary.
The liver converts growth hormone to
insulin-like growth factor 1, which
has several effects throughout the
body. Its main role is to increase
protein synthesis, lipid catabolism,
and bone growth.
Although growth hormone has many
benefits for those who are
congenitally deficient, it does not
hold similar promise for healthy young
athletes. There is no conclusive
evidence that growth hormone enhances
athletic performance. Use of exogenous
growth hormone requires a
prescription, but athletes are easily
able to obtain it over the internet.
Growth hormone is banned by all major
sporting leagues.
However, no reliable test to detect
use by athletes has been developed.
Nearly 5% of 10th graders have used
growth hormone for enhanced athletic
performance purposes. It is typically
injected several times per month, and
the cost of a 1-month supply can
approach $5000. Athletes who take
growth hormone often combine it with
anabolic steroids. Side effects of
exogenous growth hormone include
acromegaly, myopathy, hypertension,
papilledema with intracranial
hypertension, and premature closure of
growth plates.
Anabolic
Steroids and Steroid Precursors
Most anabolic steroids are synthetic
versions of testosterone or
testosterone precursors. This male sex
hormone is responsible for sex
characteristics and the growth of
skeletal muscle. More than 100
anabolic steroids or steroid
precursors are on the market.
Trade names for these steroids
include Anadrol, Anavar, Winstrol, and
Oxadrin. Examples of steroid
precursors are androstenedione and
DHEA. Slang terms commonly used for
these products are roids, hype,
andro, pump, and juice.
These products are available
legally, by prescription only, to
treat certain medical conditions such
as delayed puberty, muscle wasting,
and some breast cancers.
Unfortunately, these products are
easily available over the internet
without legitimate, legal
prescriptions. Athletes engaged in
endurance and strength-focused sports
are the most likely to use steroids.
Steroids are used to increase muscle
mass, to train faster and longer, and
to reduce recovery time.
Anabolic steroids have very
dangerous side effects that include
bone growth arrest; heart, kidney, and
liver damage; high cholesterol;
testicular atrophy; diabetes, mood
swings; aggressive behavior;
depression; fluid retention and acne.
The use of anabolic steroids, and of
the steroid precursor androstenedione,
are banned by all athletic
associations. DHEA remains an
over-the-counter nutritional
supplement. Although DHEA is a legal
supplement, impurities during
production can place athletes at risk
for testing positive for a banned
substance.
Advice to
Parents and Athletes
Health care professionals play an
important role in reducing the use of
ergogenic aids in athletes. The best
sports performance enhancers are
adequate water, carbohydrates, and
electrolytes.
For kids, adequate water
intake is the most important exercise
supplement. For vigorous or
long-lasting exercise, sports drinks
with electrolytes and snacks with
sufficient carbohydrates should be
used.
|
|
Encourage parents of athletes to educate
themselves about the risks of products
that children are buying in stores or
over the internet.
Teach parents and
athletes to be extremely cautious of
supplement information on the
internet. Most websites are trying to
sell a product and provide very
biased, unscientific information.
Discuss the health risks associated
with products and encourage parents to
do the same.
Advise parents to ask their child’s
coach what rules are in place to
reduce the use of these products, and
what the school is doing to help
educate athletes about ergogenic use.
|
Sources of
information
for parents and families:
|
|